PLAYERS TASKS PRAXIS TEAMS EVENTS
Username:Password:
New player? Sign Up Here
Betsy
Level 1: 10 points
Alltime Score: 765 points
Last Logged In: August 5th, 2010
TEAM: NY0


retired

15 + 40 points

The Death of Public Life In The Age of Insatiability by Betsy

March 24th, 2008 7:38 AM

INSTRUCTIONS: Document all the public actions you take in a day. Additionally, document all the private actions you take that same day.

Graph your actions.

Idea:
Since I want to learn something about myself from this task, as well as exhibit my life for others, I decided to collect additional data that might answer a question I didn't know the answer to. I considered what quantifiable data would be readily available at any point in the day, but not under my conscious control. Counting how many people smile at me, for instance, could easily be affected by cues I gave them, and would be very dull for the private actions, to boot.

Thus, my task will answer the question: Does BetZ exhibit higher anxiety in public situations than in private situations? I will use pulse as a proxy for social stress, controlling for potential physical stressors exertion and food consumption.

Methodology:
Roughly every half hour, and during discrete actions, I will take my pulse at the radial artery over 15 seconds, and note the following variables:
Action in process (text)
Public or private (binary)
Level of exertion (text, possibly converted to a scale upon completion)
Number of minutes since last food or drink

During the study, I added variables to cover other potentially relevant factors, such as whether music was involved, whether music was slow or fast, and whether I was singing.

Data Collection:
There seems to be a social taboo against checking one's pulse, outside of the gym or doctor's office. It's also difficult to scribble notes on a paper in public without appearing crazy. Nonetheless, I was able to record most of my actions, with slight delay on some. My pulse-taking and watch-watching technique may have improved slightly over the course of the day.

Results:
Pulse was higher in public situations than private, even controlling for level of exertion; this effect is statistically significant at the 1%, 5%, and 10% levels in some regressions, but not provably different from zero in others, depending on the specification.  The number of minutes since undertaking heavy exertion was also important to control for;  using a logarithmic value of number of minutes since heavy exertion strengthened the effect and created a better fit for the entire regression model.

Listening to music, fast or slow, did not affect pulse, but singing did.  Regression 16 seems to be the most explanatory regression, taking into account the effects of being in public, various activity level indicators, the log of the time since heavy exertion, and whether I'm singing.  However, the next best fit is regression 18, which drops the original variable of interest (being in public or private), but keeps the singing dummy.  Regression 13, which does not include the singing indicator, but does include the public/private variable, is the next best fit, according to adjusted R-squared.

Being late did not raise pulse, after controlling for the exertion of running for a bus, etc.

Discussion:
Although the results are not conclusive, they suggest that celebrities and the homeless may be at risk for a heart attack related to high pulse, due to constantly being in the public sphere, coupled with likely cocaine use (not a variable covered in this study).  Recording artists and buskers may face additional risk because they engage in the high-pulse activity of singing, as well;  some should consider the risk management approach Ashlee Simpson and Milli Vanilli have so famously employed (i.e., not actually singing).  However, further study is needed.

Bibliography:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse

- smaller

Documentation of 1:45 PM: "Brooklyn" and "Queenie"

Documentation of 1:45 PM:  "Brooklyn" and "Queenie"

From a litter of five, originally named after the boroughs of NYC, these bunnies are looking for a home!


Documentation of 1:45 PM: Bunnies grazing

Documentation of 1:45 PM:  Bunnies grazing

They seem more interested in food than in the multi-colored toy that must be a bunny Rubik's cube.


Documentation of 2:30 PM: Lunch and Work

Documentation of 2:30 PM:  Lunch and Work

Work without lunch is like nectar in a sieve...


Day documentation data

Day documentation data

Read all about it!


Spreadsheet version

Spreadsheet version

This Excel file contains all of the data collected and the resulting regressions. Also, it all looks pretty (the fonts didn't register properly in the PDF version).


Stata Do file for analysis

Stata Do file for analysis

I told Stata what to do. Run, Stata, Run!


Stata Log File

Stata Log File

Stata ran quickly. Good Stata!


Scatterplot: Pulse over time

Scatterplot:  Pulse over time

There was a slight upward trend in pulse throughout the day, before controlling for levels of exertion, etc. Note that the unfriendly axis time2 is in units of milliseconds since midnight, or some such thing.


Regression Results

Regression Results

Regression 16 is most explanatory. It concludes that being in public has a not quite statistically significant effect raising pulse. Hurrah for science!



8 vote(s)



Terms

(none yet)

2 comment(s)

(no subject)
posted by susy derkins on March 24th, 2008 8:45 AM

I still would like to know how many people smile at you in a day.
One smile here.

(no subject)
posted by Loki on March 26th, 2008 8:25 PM

Hooray for precision tasking.