PLAYERS TASKS PRAXIS TEAMS EVENTS
Username:Password:
New player? Sign Up Here
K prime
Level 4: 408 points
Alltime Score: 1403 points
Last Logged In: March 21st, 2010
The University of Aesthematics Rank 3: Graffito
highscore

retired

25 + 115 points

Honest Mail by K prime, Spidere

October 5th, 2007 1:56 AM

INSTRUCTIONS: Write a few letters or postcards. Address and stamp them. Leave them about your town and see how many of them get mailed back to you

We really wanted to do this task, because it sounded like such fun to get postcards from random people and see what they would say! We knew that we wouldn't get them all back, but the potential payoff seemed like so much fun, we couldn't resist. 20 postcards (the amount we could send using two full books of postcard stamps) seemed like a good amount, enough to make it likely we'd get at least some sort of response (for those who want to skip to the end: we got 4 postcards back--they're the first 1 and last 3 pictures below).

While we were buying postcards from a DC tourist shop, we kept seeing the president's face. So we decided to try a little experiment. Instead of 20 random postcards, we got 10 different DC postcards...and 10 copies of the George W. Bush postcard. On the 10 DC postcards, we wrote "Who are you?" and on the Bush postcards, "What do you think?" On both, we added the Warmice address and a little bit of explanation: "This is part of a collaborative postcard project. Please write something about yourself, mail it, and see the results online. http://sfzero.org/tasks/Honest-Mail"

Kprime did all the handwriting, because we wanted them to be legible (Spidere's handwriting looks like a kindergartener's or a psychopath's). While she was doing that, Spidere got two packs of blue pens, to leave with the postcards. The idea, by adding instructions, plenty of open space, and leaving a pen right with each one, was to make it as easy as possible for people to respond. The fewer barriers to doing something, I've found, the more people you can actually get to do it. It's sort of surprising, but it's more important than how interesting it is, or how good...making something easy to participate in makes a huge difference.

After we'd prepared them, we started placing the postcards at various places around town, where we hoped people would pick them up and give interesting responses.

The first was left in the ice cream shop where we'd prepared the cards. Two in an independent movie theater. Most were left in a bookstore, hidden in various interesting books for people to find. One in a nearby international hotel. One at FedEx. One at McDonald's. The last three on the metro.

We wanted to strike a balance...between making them easy to find, where people would quickly see them and give us a response (but they could also be cleaned up and thrown away by the normal staff) and being more hidden (where they might sit for months, but were less likely to be noticed by people who might not care). So we may yet get more responses as people find some of the more hidden bookstore postcards--we'll scan them in and post them if we do.

The only Bush postcard we've received was blank, received the day after we left the cards (probably not even examined, just a good samaritan dropping the card in the mail). Maybe it's a harder question that people don't have an easy answer to? Or something they don't want to publicize on a postcard?

In any case, the three filled-out "Who are you?" postcards were each interesting, and a real treat to receive. Great task!

+ larger

First received
Filled out cards and pens
Who are you?
What do you think?
10 George W. Bush Postcards
Left one
Left two
The White House
Left three
The Air and Space Museum
Left four
Left five
20070906031522_p5_we_the_people.JPG
Left six
20070906031548_p7_capitol_night.JPG
Left seven
Left eight
The Jefferson Memorial
Left nine
Left ten
Left eleven
Left twelve
The National Cathedral
Left thirteen
The WWII Memorial
Left fourteen
Left fifteen
Left sixteen
Left seventeen
The Pentagon
Left eighteen
The Capitol Building and Garden
Left nineteen
The Capitol Building
Left twenty
Second received
Third received
Fourth received

23 vote(s)



Terms

(none yet)

10 comment(s)

Experimental results for the curious
posted by Spidere on October 5th, 2007 2:29 AM

By the way, a statistical test of significance indicates that given the replies, there is not enough evidence to show a correlation between the type of postcard (DC vs. Bush) and whether or not people send it in. P-value of 0.582 (0.2105 if you count the empty Bush card as a no-reply), using Fisher's two-sided exact test for categorical data.

Wow.
posted by Loki on October 5th, 2007 3:32 AM

Absolutely lovely. Giving out blanks with a prompt is a brilliant take on the task, and I love the drop locations.

Also, extra cool points for a rigorous statistical analysis. Hooray for precision in all things. Even silly things.

Hope some of your correspondents show up here. I'd rather like to meet (and acknowledge) the REAL emailer.

(no subject)
posted by Malaysian Eddy on October 5th, 2007 10:38 AM

Ohhh...this is making me miss home. Did they ever open up the newseum again? I really hope you guys get some of the mailed back to you!!

(no subject)
posted by Adam on October 5th, 2007 2:00 PM

What a lovely completon. If only we had thought about including biros with our postcards in our completion. We only recieved one out of 6 back and that was blank :(

So clever!
posted by The Villain on October 5th, 2007 7:07 PM

Leaving the pens was an excellent idea. I bet you'll get a GW one back. If I saw one of those, I'd be way too tempted to not to do it.

(no subject)
posted by YellowBear on October 5th, 2007 9:21 PM

I really like! Wish i would find a postcard like that somewhere...

(no subject)
posted by Ben Yamiin on October 6th, 2007 11:44 AM

Hehe! I like!

(no subject)
posted by Charlie Fish on October 12th, 2007 8:10 AM

Damn the Royal Mail postal strike. I wanna do this task.

NERDS!
posted by Frostbeard on December 14th, 2007 8:59 PM

Fisher's two-sided exact test....NERDS! Anyway, i actually appreciate it. It'd be interesting if you got a statistical result (although your starting n=20 makes that probably unlikely). Nice task. I don't really know if it fits the exact spirit of the task in its original inception, but your take makes it all that more interesting. Good job thinking this one through!

(no subject)
posted by Coreopsis Major Bloden Melen on February 9th, 2008 9:08 PM

Beautiful work, guys. Such a great narrative, too! I'm showing this completion to friends because it has such potential to inspire others to play, since I have no fellow players near me. Thank you!