PLAYERS TASKS PRAXIS TEAMS EVENTS
Username:Password:
New player? Sign Up Here
teh Lolbrarian
Level 1: 30 points
Alltime Score: 1523 points
Last Logged In: August 7th, 2010
TEAM: Team FOEcakes
highscore

retired



25 + 120 points

Bibliophile by teh Lolbrarian

May 1st, 2008 5:59 PM

INSTRUCTIONS: Check out "suspicious" library books in an attempt to be flagged by the the FBI. List specific books.

This is an excellent task for the lolbrarian. Ahh, research.

Step 1: Determine what might have the best chance of being flagged as "suspicious." This turns out to be rather difficult.
The American Library Association has this to say about the USA Patriot Act
More on the relevant section 215 from the ACLU
The ALA on privacy and library records
A Library Journal article on protecting privacy

And The Library Awareness Program gives me a glimpse of the FBI's history of interest in my library books.

And Here's what the FBI has to say about it. I'm a US citizen, so allegedly I cannot be investigated based only on checking out some books, but you never know what else in my history the FBI might think suspicious. Looks like my best bet would be to find books that might relate to "international terrorism or clandestine intelligence activities".

Now, it's quite difficult to determine what would really alarm the FBI, given that gag orders and secrecy abound in these cases. So I must use my judgment and creativity as well as my research skills. Also, I've decided to collect a variety of materials, both because this makes life more interesting, and because this way my stacks of books look freaky (e.g. I'm not researching one "questionable" topic, but a bunch of unrelated ones), so there's more chance of someone being alarmed by *something* in there.

Step 2: Assess area library privacy policies-- am I more likely to get flagged one place than another?
The University's policy was buried here
. Area public ibrary policies are not posted on the interwebs. I am given to understand that they are fairly standard in terms of being in line with the ALA's stance on privacy. For the edification of my fellow players, here is an exemplary privacy policy from the Skokie Public Library. And here's A detailed policy discussing the ramifications of the USA PATRIOT Act.

Step 3: Check out books!

To establish a pattern of "deviance," and because I can only fit so many books in my backpack, I will take a few trips to the university and public libraries. Why do I not just return the books immediately (assuming I don't want to read them)? Most libraries dump checkout records once materials have been returned for privacy reasons (as well as "we don't want to keep track of a ton of data" reasons), so if I keep books out for awhile there's more opportunity for the Feds to request my records.

Methodology: Poke around the catalog for suspicious subject headings (e.g. ones related to terrorism) and note where books under these headings are. Go there and browse around. That way if I see books which look even *more* suspicious and alarming than what I happen to find in the catalog, I can get those!

Trip #1: Terrorism, Sex, and Drugs!
We return to the university library (last seen in Taking Pleasure in Institutional Life, so I hope you appreciate what I'm subjecting myself to) for this one.

Moats, Jason B. Agroterrorism: A Guide for First Responders.

Davis, Lois M. , Louis T. Mariano, Jennifer E. Pace, Sarah K. Cotton, and Paul Steinberg. Combating Terrorism: How Prepared Are State and Local Response Organizations?

Phares, Walid. Future Jihad: Terrorist Strategies Against America. New York: Palgrave MacMillan, 2005.

Califa, Patrick. Sensuous Magic: A guide to S/M for Adventurous Couples.

Bright, Susie. Full Exposure: Opening Up to Your Sexual Creativity & Erotic Expression.

Beck, Jerome and Marsha Rosenbaum. Pursuit of Ecstasy: The MDMA Experience. Albany: State University of New York Press. 1994.

Note: We'd like to think the FBI doesn't care about sex, but can we be sure? Also, these serve as an additional red flag to anyone with access to information about what I've checked out-- oh noes, naughty books! In the library! Scandalous! What *are* they teaching those undergrads? And hey, the first one seemed quite appropriate given my last task in the library.)


Trip #2: Moar terrorism+ overthrowing the government (at the public library)

This wasn't the most fruitful public library trip-- they don't have the world's largest nonfiction collection. Note to self: make list of suspicious fiction. In the meantime...

These books were checked out using a self-checkout system, as staff were busy. But this system has a large screen that people can see, so perhaps someone will report my suspicious checkouts. Plus the system uses RFID tags in the books, so maybe the FBI is *tracking my books right now*.

Anarchist voices : an oral history of anarchism in America /
by Avrich, Paul.

Eco-terrorism : radical environmental and animal liberation movements /
by Liddick, Don.

How to overthrow the government /
by Huffington, Arianna Stassinopoulos, 1950-

Terror on the Internet : the new arena, the new challenges /
by Weimann, Gabriel, 1950-

Trip #3: Terrorism and Still More Questionable Reading Matter at the Other Public Library
9-11 /
by Chomsky, Noam.

Agents of repression : the FBI's secret wars against the Black Panther Party and the American Indian Movement /
by Churchill, Ward.

The Al Qaeda reader /
by Ibrahim, Raymond.

Green Arrow : quiver /
by Smith, Kevin, 1970-

Embroideries /
by Satrapi, Marjane, 1969-

Note: The last two are graphic novels. As we know, comics are a grave danger to the children and should not be in the library! These are very suspicious. And the last one is about people from Iran (and by the author of the excellent Persepolis)-- a double whammy of suspiciousness!

Trip #4: The Wide World of Government Documents

Much as it might not want to, the government is supposed to make its unclassified documents and proceedings available to the public. The university here, like many, is a government documents repository. So all I must do to obtain reading materials about nuclear waste and whatnot is brave the labyrinthine library once again, foil the compact shelving's attempt to thwart me, and stave off the boredom of looking at many shelves full of books with identical bindings about really boring senate proceedings. But I came out with these two suspicious-looking items.

United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. Civilian radioactive waste disposal : hearings before the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, United States Senate, One hundredth Congress, first session, on S. 1007 ... S. 1141 ... S. 1211 ... S. 1266 ... S. 1428 ... July 16 and 17, 1987.

Radioactivity in consumer products / edited by A. Alan Moghissi ... [et al.].

- smaller

A bag of suspicious books. Yes, I packed it myself.

A bag of suspicious books. Yes, I packed it myself.


Suspicious Books Are Suspicious

Suspicious Books Are Suspicious


Terrorism *and* Seduction of the Innocent! What next?

Terrorism *and* Seduction of the Innocent! What next?


Suspicious material courtesy of... the US government!

Suspicious material courtesy of... the US government!



24 vote(s)



Terms

foecake, foecakefleur

11 comment(s)

hmm.
posted by meredithian on May 1st, 2008 6:30 PM

i think this task is fantastic. what's more amazing is that a few people have done it and no one has checked out any of the books that spring to my mind when i think of stuff that's bound to get you flagged by the FBI

i think steal this book and the anarchist cookbook - if you can find them in a library - might be at the top of this suspicious books list. also, maybe, jello biafra stuff? like his spoken word cds? what about documents from and books about the SDS or the weathermen? the chicago 10? actually, i bet just researching the patriot act itself will get you flagged.

maybe you could just check out a lot of books on code breaking and cryptography, amateur radio transmitting, and numbers stations. or a lot of 50's communist agenda tracts an manifestos, along with transcripts and government docs or books about mccarthy hearing stuff. maybe writings of emma goldberg? you could try to request via interlibrary loan the sacco and vinzetti case files/hearing transcripts. or check out TONS of JFK Assasination/Fake Moon Landing/Elvis/Area 51/Marilyn Monroe conspiracy theory stuff.

or perhaps track down and check out every available copy in the chicagoland area of catcher in the rye?

(no subject)
posted by teh Lolbrarian on May 1st, 2008 6:54 PM

The neat thing about this task is that there are so many approaches. I could've kept checking out all kinds of things forever, but I did want to submit this task at some point.

The Anarchist's Cookbook is actually difficult to check out. Many libraries that have it keep it in Special Collections (generally for rare materials you don't want to circulate); in some cases I suspect it's that they've decided that they do want to limit access to it, and in many cases I understand it's because it gets stolen repeatedly (all of the university's copies that *aren't* in the rare books library are missing-- I checked!).

(no subject)
posted by meredithian on May 1st, 2008 10:21 PM

yeah, i think all the really good stuff is in special collections. ;)

i just like seeing what different people come up with. all the things that sprung to my mind i think are obvious or something. i like to see what kinds of titles are out there that i didn't know about, that, yeah, probably would get you flagged.

many of the titles make me curious as to the actual contents of the books; are they really what they seem or do they just have a provocative title? who writes books about, literally, *how* to overthrow a government?

i really wish there were a way to check. it would be more amazing to see what actually gets people flagged. who knows, taking too keen an interest in martha steward could put you on somebody's watch list.

anyway, great completion! very thorough.

The voice of experience
posted by zer0gee on May 1st, 2008 11:18 PM

Taking photos of oil refineries in the industrial suburbs of New Orleans is one thing that will definitely get you flagged by the FBI. And Homeland Security.

(no subject)
posted by teh Lolbrarian on May 2nd, 2008 7:44 AM

The overthrowing the government book is mostly a book about liberal activism-- Huffington is a well-known political blogger. So it's not about violently overthrowing the government, but if the FBI is trying to data-mine library records, this is the kind of thing that would get flagged (note: they're absolutely not supposed to be able to do bulk requests like that, and frankly I don't see that you'd get much useful evidence from library books except in a case where, say, library records proved you checked out a book found at the scene of the crime, or something equally ridiculous, and it's not as if the FBI has revealed anything about how many terrorists they've caught this way).

I think _Combating Terrorism: How Prepared Are State and Local Response Organizations?_ is actually the most exciting book in the list-- after all, if I read their report, I know what the flaws in the system are. And government documents has a lot of unexplored potential, it's just that I'm (relatively) lazy.

(no subject) +1
posted by Samantha on May 1st, 2008 7:10 PM

Your tasking makes me happy, but placing ms. satrapi's book in there doesn't.

(no subject)
posted by teh Lolbrarian on May 1st, 2008 9:26 PM

I thought I made this fairly clear in my note at the bottom of that list, but in case it isn't: I included Ms. Satrapi's book as a comment on current perceptions of graphic novels, and of Iran. I don't think this particular book is actually that likely to be flagged as suspicious, but it served to illustrate something about what the US media and politicians currently consider suspicious. I agree with mat defiler about this task and the lists of books people have submitted.

People will object to the darndest things...

(no subject)
posted by The Animus on May 1st, 2008 10:57 PM

I agree with the edge-having. Great tasking.

(no subject)
posted by El Neil on September 18th, 2008 5:36 AM

The Al Qaeda reader. fantastic!

1 vote to you, good sir.

(no subject)
posted by Dopey on September 18th, 2008 10:02 AM

i double on that...my vote for the Al Qaeda reader...what was it like to check out so many books at once? *dialogue with the check out person wouldve been nice
"hi howre you today"
"oh good...good *evil smirk"
*librarian scans book after book of "terrorism...for DUMMIES" and calls popos

(no subject)
posted by teh Lolbrarian on September 18th, 2008 2:35 PM

Well, this wasn't so many books at once when you consider that this involved trips to multiple libraries. As for dialogue with the checkout people, I know that it's not considered appropriate to talk about patrons' books unless they start a conversation. It's also considered bad practice to make assumptions about why people want information-- sometimes it's not helpful professionally because you're not giving people the information they're actually looking for, and otherwise it's just inappropriate-- privacy's definitely a part of the professional ethics. Which is not to say that no one would call the police over this stack of books in today's climate (the point of the task, of course), just that they shouldn't. This is also why I didn't try to start any weird conversations with the folks checking my books out for me-- the task isn't about disturbing library staff, it's about the books and only the books, as I see it.