
Pure Evil by Darkaardvark
August 26th, 2010 11:44 PMAs you may know from some of my previous praxes, I was really into crosswords for a while. I'm still into crosswords, but not in as a big a way. Anyhow, back when I was really into crosswords, I sat down and actually made a crossword. This is harder than it sounds, and in fact despite efforts, I haven't been able to duplicate the attempt.
That may be because this crossword is no ordinary crossword. It is an evil crossword, a PURE EVIL crossword.
So evil, in fact, that it was rejected, out of sheer terror, by none other than Will Shortz himself, editor of the New York Times puzzles. This is true.
So, be warned: Solve at your own peril. This crossword was the inspiration for at least one of H.P. Lovecraft's stories- that I know of- and there is increasing evidence that Edvard Munch's "The Scream" was a response to this puzzle.
TURN BACK NOW
If you are foolish, and do wish to solve it, you have a few options:
1. The clues are in the proof here and the grid is attached as an image. Use these however you see fit.
2. The grid and clues are in a .rtf file, ready to print from Word and solve with pencil. I urge you to avoid using pen. I absolve myself of any resultant apocalypse.
3. The easiest way to solve would be in Across Lite, which is very lightweight and can be downloaded here. Unfortunately, I can't upload the puzzle file to sf0, but find me on Skype (darkaardvark1) or message me and I'll get the file to you.
In all seriousness, quite a lot of effort went into making this puzzle, and editing, including a peer edit by someone who is regularly published in the New York Times. I hope at least some of you will take the time to look it over. I'll give out the solution to anyone whose interested and anyone who actually solves this thing will have my undying respect and gratitude.
ABANDON ALL HOPE
Across
1. Representatives are sent there – 7. Baker's amt. – 11. Poetry's cousin – 14. Step gaily – 15. "___ Window" (Hitchcock thriller) – 16. "Dracula" director Browning – 17. John of football commentary – 18. Salinger title girl – 19. One was written on an urn – 20. ___ in the neck – 21. Conservative institute – 22. Largest of the Marianas – 23. It may be lost in stressful times – 24. Native Oklahomans – 25. Major and Minor constellation – 26. Biblical birthright seller – 28. Bit of truth – 30. Tack on – 33. Frigid – 35. Macho bodybuilder – 39. Consider the options, or a title for this puzzle – 44. Follow as a result – 45. Hub northwest of L.A. – 46. ___ bind (stuck) – 47. Boring tools – 50. Gp. with many barrels – 53. California vulture – 56. Eye lasciviously – 58. "Sure!" – 62. Pal on the range – 63. Armenian composer Khachaturian – 64. Mimicry – 65. Noshed – 66. Send out – 67. Swore – 68. 'Mr. Anderson', in "The Matrix" – 69. Sir, to a lady – 70. Go-____ – 71. Start of start – 72. ___ of Wight – 73. It shares the Diomede Islands with Russia.
Down
1. Set-builder – 2. Vine fruit – 3. WWII detection invention – 4. Belgian green – 5. Act divisions – 6. Hatch or Reid: Abbr. – 7. Take out to dinner, say – 8. Greatest hits collection – 9. Indian appetizer – 10. Heated opener – 11. Map that shows elevation – 12. Pops in the Northeast – 13. Plant swelling – 21. Freud's furniture – 22. ___ Tag – 27. Island in a river – 29. Half a dance? – 30. Stunned admiration – 31. Lion's haunt – 32. Belittle, slangily – 34. Not no – 36. Start of the 16th century – 37. Where "Kiss the Cook" is
written – 38. CIA counterpart – 40. Watch over – 41. Carve, perhaps from stone – 42. Refuse to go againt the grain – 43. Soak (up) – 48. Camel cousins – 49. Story published piecemeal – 51. Crown cover – 52. Per ___ – 53. Grill gas – 54. Goes out with – 55. Dunkable cookies – 57. Alice's cake's command – 59. Tries out – 60. Stream – 61. Beast of Hercules' second labor – 66. Record company of Abbey Road: Abbr. – 67. Line dance.

Crossword Grid

Look at that lovely symmetry. Did you know crossword puzzle grids need to be symmetrical across the diagonal?
Email from Will Shortz

Proof that I did send this to NYT. Content censored to protect the souls of the test solvers who were maimed in the solving.
9 vote(s)

Brock Dubbels
5
Sir Pinkleton
5
Dela Dejavoo
5
Sombrero Guy
3
teucer
2
Flitworth
5
Picø ҉ ØwO
5
Togashi Ni
5
Idøntity matrix
Terms
(none yet)12 comment(s)
I really like what you've done here. And I appreciate the work that went into it, and in lieu of a vote I'm going to let the 125 base points tell you how I feel about it.
I will also try to solve it... someday.
Fair enough. A few minutes after submitting this I had an "Oh crap, that was 125 points?" moments. But I stand by it.
I think you deserve the 125 for the work you put in, just not 125+my 5. But good work, I look forward to trying to solve it. One of these days when I have time.
The size of my vote will be determined by whether I solve it, or give up in frustration. I can already tell it's evil; the only question is how evil.
(If I'd solved it by now, I'd probably flag it as not evil enough for the base value. But it totally is. And I say this as a fan of cryptics.)
Hmm. I spent half an hour on this, before falling asleep now - not managing to solve it all and probably being wrong here and there, but I think it's definitely not evil enough. It was hard to come up with some of the words, but the clues were way too straightforward. I expected them to actively lead you into wrong directions. Well, for that score at least. I totally enjoyed the crossword. :)
I guess you native speakers / US locals will have less trouble.
[MASSIVE SPOILER]
(Actually I expected to notice that the puzzle was somehow ingeniously unsolvable or ambiguous after spending lots of time trying to sove it, or something like that)
Will Shortz did a brilliant political one on the morning after one of the elections. (I think it was 2000.) It had two possible solutions, one of which mentioned one candidate winning and the other mentioning the other. The relevant clue was something like "Today's Headline," too, so you knew it was wrong if you found the solution with the other candidate.
relet: it seems not evil enough because you haven't solved it properly. that's all I can say without spoiling anything.
teucer: That was a brilliant one. The answer was, I think, BOBDOLEELECTED or CLINTONELECTED and all the clues worked both ways (e.g. "Black halloween animal" for BAT/CAT). What's brilliant is that this allowed the crossword puzzle to be incredibly topical even though the lead time for puzzles is usually like 6 months. Awesomeness.
Heh, that's awesome. :)
And you're certainly right about the evil lurking where I couldn't spot it yet. If I find a quiet moment, I'll try to uncover more of it, or just wait until someone else does. :)
this puzzle didn't seem evil... more ambivalent... i had my partner solve it separately, just in case there was a hidden shadow-puzzle that i didn't see (he's good at that kind of thing.) but he got the same answers. is it more subtle than that?
i did lose the first copy i printed, so presumably it could be lurking in the house plotting diabolical acts, but unless mysterious bad things start to befall me i don't think this puzzle was evil. and if they do, i'm mad at you. you should have labeled it "really actually evil, the unpleasant kind, not a fun Vincent Pricey evil."
it had a clever twist; does that count as evil these days? maybe i should message you, so there are not spoilers for those who have not yet completed it.
that is what evil is, the action that you know is unspoken.
was Salinger's Title girl evil?
why didn't you have lasersharks?
Those are evil.
I've never been good at crosswords, but that's not going to stop me trying...